A Comparative Analysis of "Alien Interview" and L. Ron Hubbard's Scientology: Linguistic, Chronological, and Conceptual Perspectives

My argument is that "Alien Interview" predates and influenced Hubbard's Scientology, rather than the other way around. The following analysis presents a compelling argument about the origin and authenticity of "Alien Interview" compared to L. Ron Hubbard's works, particularly in the context of Scientology. Here are some key points that support the idea that Hubbard may have borrowed heavily from sources like "Alien Interview" rather than the reverse:

Linguistic Analysis:

Clarity in "Alien Interview":

The language in "Alien Interview" is straightforward and accessible, designed to be easily understood by a wide audience. This contrasts with the often convoluted and jargon-heavy language found in Hubbard's writings. For example, usage of the word "is-be" is because it has explanatory power.

Complexity in Scientology:

Hubbard employs complex English, using synonyms for simple words and specialized jargon like "MEST" (Matter, Energy, Space, and Time). This complexity can create barriers to understanding and serves to obfuscate and mystify, which is not present in the "Alien Interview."

Chronological Context:

"Alien Interview" (1947): Supposedly compiled immediately after the Roswell incident, based on interviews conducted in mid-1947.

Scientology (Post-1950): Developed by Hubbard starting with "Dianetics" in 1950 and evolving into Scientology in the early 1950s. Hubbard's "Excalibur" story, often cited as the foundational text for his later works, dates from 1948.

Conceptual Overlaps:

1.Immortality and Spiritual Beings:

"Alien Interview": Discusses IS-BEs (Immortal Spiritual Beings), a concept that is clear and self-explanatory.

Scientology: Introduces the term "thetan" to describe an immortal being, often couched in complex terminology and philosophical constructs.

2.Civilizations and Extraterrestrial Influence:

"Alien Interview": References "The Domain" and "Old Empire," described in a direct and comprehensible manner.

Scientology: Mentions entities like the "Marcab Confederacy" and various invader forces, often requiring deeper immersion into Scientology's unique jargon.

Evidence and Plausibility:

Hubbard's Story of "Excalibur": Hubbard's account of "Excalibur," which he claimed contained profound metaphysical secrets, aligns with the timing of the Roswell incident and the subsequent "Alien Interview." This suggests he might have had access to similar sources or inspiration.

Conclusion:

Given the timeline and the distinct differences in language and presentation, it is reasonable to propose that "Alien Interview" could be an independent and original account predating Hubbard's works on Scientology. The simplicity and clarity of the language in "Alien Interview" further support its authenticity as a separate narrative rather than a derivative work influenced by Hubbard.

Final Thoughts:

This analysis, supported by linguistic, chronological, and conceptual evidence, strongly suggests that "Alien Interview" predates and potentially influenced Hubbard's Scientology. This perspective challenges the notion that "Alien Interview" is merely a product of a Scientologist's imagination, instead suggesting it could be a foundational document from which Hubbard drew inspiration for his complex philosophical and spiritual framework.